HB Tansu Progress-7

As of today I’ve built a grand total of (7) drawers in my woodworking “career”.  Feel free to take a moment and let the magnitude of that number fully sink in.  OK, I know that is pretty damn pitiful, but it speaks volumes as to my experience with case and cabinet work. To be honest, drawers use to intimidate me.  So I avoided building projects that called for them.  Most publications talked about drawer construction as if it was the most complicated and difficult task a woodworker could possibly undertake.  As a beginner woodworker you would have a better chance saddle breaking a unicorn than building a functional drawer.  Which is total bullshit by the way.  Anyone can build a solid and functional drawer.  I’ve got (7) to prove it.  Of course there will be varying degrees of success and “pretty”.  But, like with all woodworking tasks, quantity leads to quality.  The more drawers you build, the better you will be at it.  Trust me though, it takes more than (7) to become proficient at it.

From what I have been able to discover, the Japanese method of drawer construction is quite different from that of the European tradition.  In the European tradition, thou shalt join the front to the sides with half blind (lapped) dovetails.  Thou shalt install the back to the sides with thru dovetails or install the back into a housing dado.  The bottom is to be installed into a groove that runs along the front and down the sides and it is to be nailed or screwed to the back piece.  Not so much in the Japanese tradition.

The Japanese tradition seems to be that the front is joined to the sides with a pegged rebate joint.  The back is joined to the sides with a pegged finger joint.  Then the front is rebated to receive the bottom which is then glued and pegged to the drawer assembly.  No dovetails and no grooves.  At first glance this seems like poor construction.  On closer inspection I think that this method makes for a very strong drawer.  With the pegged joints and the bottom glued and pegged to all the members, I would imagine that this type of drawer is very rigid indeed.  Which may be the drawback.  Several of the antique examples that I’ve seen photos of, have splits in their bottoms.  No allowance for wood movement.  The rest of joints seem to stand the test of time though.  Here are a couple of links to videos that show master craftsman building drawers in the Japanese style.  Here and here.

So what about drawer #7?  Drawer #7 is an amalgamation, or bastardization, depending on how you view it, of several bits of information that I have come across.  I joined the front to the sides with half blind dovetails and the back was joined to the sides with thru dovetails.  The bottom is installed into a groove that runs along the front and down the sides.  Nothing controversial so far.  As a nod to Japanese craftsmen I pegged my dovetails and also pegged the bottom to the rear of the drawer with wooden pegs that I made.  These shop made pegs worked OK but I think I’m going to try using bamboo skewers on the next drawer.  Pinned dovetails is nothing new and Paul Sellers wrote a blog entry about them a while back.  You can read that entry here.

All in all I’m happy with the way my drawer turned out.  The dovetails are nothing to get excited about, but the drawer is solid and square.  My biggest concern was the fitting of the drawer to the opening.  This is my main reason for building just one drawer.  I wanted to verify that my sizes would give me just enough meat for the fitting.  They did.

Greg Merritt

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Hillbilly Tansu-000 and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to HB Tansu Progress-7

  1. bloksav says:

    I like to make my drawers the traditional European way.
    First of all I like making dovetails, and by making these on the drawers I get a chance to practise them on places that won’t be visible.
    Popular woodworking had a great article some years ago by Mario Rodriguez on how he made drawers for fine furniture. http://www.popularwoodworking.com/articleindex/the-art-of-making-dovetailed-drawers

    The HB Tansu is looking really good.
    Brgds
    Jonas

    • gman3555 says:

      Thanks Jonas and thanks for the link to the article. I just bought the back issue and will be reading that article carefully tonight.

      Hey, good luck with the chair build. It’s this coming week, right?

      Best,
      Greg

      • bloksav says:

        Hi Greg.

        Yup the chair build is scheduled to start off Thursday morning at 10 o’clock.
        The plan is to sign off Wednesday, so I hope that we won’t be kept out here for any longer. If they do, Brian Eve will have to start by himself..

        My hands are itching to get back doing some woodworking. This time there haven’t really been a good opportuninty to start something out here.

        That build should give me something to blog about 🙂

        Brgds
        Jonas

  2. António, from Portugal says:

    There you are chasing your “ghosts”…
    It looks very very nice!

  3. billlattpa says:

    Making drawers is fun in my book. I’ve never attempted pegging dovetails but I should give it a shot. I think it’s looking really great.

    Bill

    • gman3555 says:

      Thanks Bill. I’m enjoying building them too. I hate that I let the process intimidate for so long. Not anymore. There is nothing fancy about pegging dovetails. Drill a hole, drive in a peg.

      I hope your getting some time in the shop. 😉

      Greg

  4. joemcglynn says:

    Greg, the fit on that drawer looks perfect. Are you going to do knotted pulls?

    • gman3555 says:

      Thanks Joe. It took an inordinate amount of time to fit that drawer. I was very nervous about making it too loose. So wispy shavings only. Check and repeat. Probably a good hour to get it fitted.

      Of course I’m using knotted pulls. These will be 4 strand star knots which will give me a square pull to compliment the exposed square tenons. Sort of a poor man’s version of the Greene and Greene ebony plugs that you use.

      Greg

If you don't comment this is just a fancy way for me to talk to myself.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s